Descriptions:
Video Description
The real divide in society is not left versus right — it is rulers versus ruled. This lecture from Academy of Ideas uses Carl Jung to expose why that gap is growing. At the top, rulers fall into psychological inflation: they identify with their titles until they believe the institution’s power lives inside them. At the bottom, ordinary people suffer psychological deflation, projecting their own hidden greatness onto leaders. The result is a feedback loop, and the video names the only way to break it: reclaim personal power, and meet tyranny with laughter.
Full Video Transcript
Become an Academy of Ideas supporting member and access over 100 membership videos,
including the first video of our latest series on Big Pharma and the Big Lie. Sign up for $6.99
a month or $59.99 a year by visiting academyofideas.com slash members. This channel is
made possible by the support of our members. Many believe that the most important social
divide in the West today is between the political left and right. Much of the discourse in the
corporate and independent media revolves around this battle, and many believe the outcome
of this battle will have existential ramifications for the future of the West.
But is this political conflict acting as a distraction from the true divide that shapes
a society, that being the age-old divide between the rulers and the ruled?
In this video we argue that the power disparity between the ruling class and the citizenry
has reached such pathological levels that a form of slavery is emerging. This slavery
is fueled by a ruling class that suffers from a pathological condition Carl Jung called
psychological inflation, and a citizenry that has become too weak and powerless to resist
the growing corporate and state takeover of almost every aspect of life.
Helplessness and weakness are the eternal experience and the eternal problem of mankind,
wrote Carl Jung. Decades of research led the American psychologist Susan Fisk to conclude
that men and women have five core social motives that are essential to psychological and social
well-being. These include the need to belong, the need to understand ourselves, other people,
and the world around us, the need for self-enhancement, which is the ability to cultivate a positive
self-image, the need for trust, whether it be trust in other people or in the effectiveness
of social institutions, and finally the need for control, autonomy, and competence over
the course of our life. Most of these needs require the possession
of personal power, for power is not merely the ability to control others, it is also
the ability to shape and influence the course of our life, or as the philosopher Bertrand
Russell stated, power is the production of intended effects. Power, therefore, is necessary
for self-enhancement and for attaining the goals that can improve our life. Furthermore,
as all social relations are structured by dynamics of power, power, or the lack thereof,
affects our ability to form healthy relationships. In his writings, Frederick Douglass, the escaped
slave turned social reformer, emphasized that what distinguishes the slave from the free
man is the level of power each possesses. In his book My Bondage and My Freedom, Douglass
defined the slave by the utter powerlessness they have to decide their own destiny. He also notes
that we have a natural aversion to powerlessness. We are attracted to the powerful, and unless we
have been psychologically broken, we aspire to power in ourselves. Or as Douglass writes,
A man without force is without the essential dignity of humanity. Human nature is so
constituted that it cannot honor a helpless man, although it can pity him, and even that it cannot
do long, if the signs of power do not arise. A free society provides individuals the opportunity
to cultivate the power required to sculpt a good life, to enhance well-being, and to cultivate
healthy relationships. Most societies in history, however, have only granted this opportunity to
members of certain classes, races, or ethnicities, as the institution of slavery reduced millions
of our ancestors to powerless agents of a master’s will. Slavery, writes the historian
Orlando Patterson, has existed from before the dawn of human history right down to the 20th
century, in the most primitive of human societies and in the most civilized. There is no region on
earth that has not at some time harbored the institution. Probably there is no group of people
whose ancestors were not at one time slaves or slaveholders.
While the West has done away with the institution of chattel slavery,
where the slave is the personal property of a master,
we are descending into a form of state slavery.
State slavery, or what amounts to totalitarian rule,
occurs when the state gains total control over the lives of its citizens
and rids them of the autonomy to create a life of their own choosing.
Under state slavery, citizens are limited in their movements,
spied on constantly, free speech is abolished, dissent is not tolerated, and to fund the massive
state apparatus that is required to maintain these suffocating levels of control, wealth is
extracted either through forced labor, direct taxation, or the indirect taxation of an inflation
of the money supply. The state slavery of totalitarianism creates a citizen who approaches
the utter powerlessness of the chattel slave, while elevating the ruling elite to the position
of masters. During Covid, most western states implemented totalitarian controls,
and while many of those controls have been walked back, the increasing power divide between the
ruling class and the average citizen is setting the stage for this form of slavery to re-emerge
in a more permanent form. Carl Jung suggested that one of the primary factors that contributes
to the rise of totalitarianism is a psychological inflation among the ruling class. Psychological
inflation is an extension of the personality, or more specifically of one’s ego, beyond healthy
limits. Or as Jung explains, psychological inflation occurs when the ego has appropriated
something that does not belong to it. The psychologically inflated individual identifies
with an unrealistic self-image that leads them to believe they are somehow better, stronger,
wiser, or more powerful than they really are. And as Jung explains, a very common instance of
psychological inflation is the humorless way in which many men identify themselves with their
business or their titles. In the political, corporate, and military realm, where those
who control the levers of state power reside, identifying with one’s title is extremely common.
Whether it be as CEO of a large corporation, President of the United States, Chief Medical
Advisor, Chairman of the Board, Speaker of the House, or Secretary of Defense, titles make the
man in the upper echelons of power. Tied to these titles are immense powers that are not a product
of the individual who holds the role, but a product of the institutions, resources, and
historical legacies that support the role. If an individual comes to identify their self-image with
one of these titles, they may come to believe that the power associated with their role resides
within themselves, rather than being a product of the social constructs that support the role.
Or as Jung explains,
approval of society. I have made an extraordinary extension of myself and have usurped qualities
which are not in me but outside me. Internalizing and identifying with the power of the state
is what accounts for the psychological inflation of the ruling class and it leads, in the words
of Jung, to an extension of the personality beyond individual limits, in other words,
a state of being puffed up. In volume 7 of his collected works Jung suggests that the
apocryphal saying attributed to King Louis XIV, Laetate se moi, I am the state, the state,
it is me, is the motto for such people. The more a man in a position of power inflates his
personality in this manner, the more he suffers from what Jung called God-almightiness. He starts
to believe that he is omnipotent, that he is above the law, that moral codes don’t apply to him and
in the process, he loses touch with reality. Or as Jung writes,
God-almightiness does not make a man divine. It merely fills him with arrogance and arouses
everything evil in him. It produces a diabolical caricature of man. And this inhuman mask is so
unendurable, such a torture to wear, that he tortures others. In order to maintain the belief
in one’s God-almightiness, members of the ruling class repress the personal weaknesses and moral
inferiorities that clash with their idealized self-image. And according to the laws of human
nature, what is repressed has a tendency to be projected onto other people. Projection is the
erroneous attribution of an individual’s unconscious qualities to the environment
or to another individual or group. And projections serve as defense mechanisms that help an
individual or group avoid facing the incompatible and disturbing contents of the psyche. The
individuals toward which we direct our projection usually possess, to one degree or another, the
traits we deny about ourselves, or as Jung explains, not that these others, the victims of
the projection, are wholly without blame, for even the worst projection is at least hung on a hook,
perhaps a very small one, but still a hook offered by the other person. The victims of a ruling
class’s projections tend to be the men and women over whom they rule, as such individuals, to one
degree or another, possess similar weaknesses, flaws, and moral inferiorities to those in
the ruling class.
This act of projection can help account for the superiority that the ruling class displays
towards its subjects.
For when we burden other people with our flaws, it is inevitable that we see them as inferior.
Throughout history there are countless examples of psychologically inflated men and women
justifying their exploitative dominance of another group, as though it were for their
own good.
Among the slaveholders of the American South, for example, Orlando Patterson wrote,
Almost all masters genuinely believed that they cared and provided for their slaves
and that it was the slaves who, in the words of one southern ex-slave owner,
had been raised to depend on others.
But what makes the psychological inflation of the ruling class even more dangerous
is that most normal people today are suffering from its mirror opposite,
a psychological deflation.
A psychological deflation is a contraction of the personality where one loses touch with character traits and potentialities that are an important part of a healthy personality.
The mechanism that causes psychological deflation is similar to that of an inflation.
It occurs when an individual identifies with a social role that is too restricted to encompass all the character traits that are needed to flourish.
Volodymyr Odechnik provides the following example in his book Young in Politics.
The members of the pariah or lower classes or members of socially despised national or racial
groups frequently identify personally with their socially defined status and roles. The result is
the atrophy of the individual personality, which fails to develop beyond the limits imposed by the
social role. Psychological deflation is no longer limited to those in the lower class, for to
identify as a normal member of society is to contract our personality and to lose touch with
our will to power. For the good citizen, in a world approaching total state control, is not
powerful and self-reliant, but obedient and docile, and the more the state controls his life, the more
powerless he becomes and the more deflated is his personality. Like psychological inflation,
psychological deflation leads to projection, but instead of projecting weaknesses and flaws,
When we deflate our personality, we project the strengths that our constricted social role has led us to deny.
When we disconnect from our need for power, for example, it becomes unconscious and primed for projection.
The most likely targets of this projection are strong political leaders, powerful political parties, or the all-powerful institution of the nation-state.
As in a world where the state is the most powerful institution, these provide easy hooks to hang our repressed will to power.
Or as the psychologist Marie-Louise von Franz explains,
There’s always been a tendency in humans to project the uniqueness and the greatness of their own inner self onto outer personalities
and become the servants, the devoted servants, admirers and imitators of outer personalities.
It is much easier to admire a great personality and become a pupil or follower of a guru or a religious prophet
it, or an admirer of a big official personality, a president of the United States, or live
your life for some military general whom you admire, that is much easier than following
your own star.
When we project our will to power onto members of the ruling class, or the institutions or
political parties they control, a dangerous feedback loop is set in motion.
The projections of the deflated masses further empower the ruling class, while the projections
of the ruling class lead them to view the citizenry as increasingly weak, dependent,
and in need of strong leaders to rule over them. This feedback loop paves the way for
the total control of state slavery, and as Jung writes,
The increasing dependence on the state is anything but a healthy symptom. It means that
the whole nation is in a fair way to becoming a herd of sheep, constantly relying on a shepherd
to drive them into good pastures.
The shepherd’s staff soon becomes a rod of iron, and the shepherds turn into wolves.
To escape from this dangerous feedback loop, responsibility lies with the citizenry, for
the inflated members of the ruling class will never voluntarily give up control.
Like the slave masters of old, they believe they are of a different breed and that without
their rule, the citizenry would run amok and chaos would ensue.
Many in society have become so deflated, so weak and psychologically fragile, that they
crave control by the state.
But for those of us who have not been psychologically broken, it is up to us to take the steps necessary
to counter the rise of state slavery.
One way to do this is to recognize our need for power and to cultivate it if we are deficient.
We can cultivate personal power through learning and mastering skills, strengthening the body,
setting goals and working toward them, or emulating powerful role models.
These steps will help counter the effects of psychological deflation and the fewer psychologically
deflated men and women in a society, the fewer who participate in the feedback loop of mutual
projections that empowers the ruling class and disempowers the citizenry.
In addition to cultivating our power, we can also disarm the power of the ruling class
with humor and ridicule.
humor is the Achilles’ heel of tyrants, as they desire to be feared and respected, not laughed at
or mocked. Laughing at those who strive to control us shatters their aura of invincibility and
reveals them as the flawed, petty, and morally inferior individuals they really are. The use of
memes, comedy skits, and satire can highlight the absurdity, contradictions, hypocrisy, and lies by
which the ruling class operates. Furthermore, humour and ridicule disarm a ruling class of
their greatest tool of oppression, that being fear. When we laugh at tyrants, we show that
we are not intimidated by them, do not admire them, and are not easy prey to their fear-based
propaganda, or as Joost Mierle explains, we must learn to treat the demagogue and aspirant
dictator in our midst with the weapon of ridicule. Humour is, after all, related to a sense of
perspective. Put the demagogue’s statements in perspective and you will see how utterly distorted
they are. How can we possibly take them seriously or answer them seriously? The demagogue relies for
his effectiveness on the fact that people will take seriously the fantastic accusations he makes,
will discuss the phony issues he raises as if they had reality, or will be thrown into such a state
of panic by his accusations and charges that they will simply abdicate their right to think and
verify for themselves. In their defense against psychological attacks on their freedom,
the people need humor and good sense first. Become an Academy of Ideas supporting member
and access over 100 membership videos, including the first video of our latest series on Big Pharma
and the Big Lie. Sign up for $6.99 a month or $59.99 a year by visiting academyofideas.com
slash members. This channel is made possible by the support of our members.
Source: Academy of Ideas